Federal Fiscal Court Holds Interests Barrier Rule Unconstitutional

Author:Dr. Hardy Fischer and Thomas Töben
Profession:P+P Pöllath + Partners
 
FREE EXCERPT

Background

According to a decision published February 10, 2016, the German Federal Fiscal Court submitted to the Federal Constitutional Court the question whether or not the interest barrier rule is unconstitutional (I R 20/15). Already in its resolution of 18/12/2013 (I B 85/13) the Federal Fiscal Court had expressed doubts about the constitutionality of the interest barrier rule. On 13/11/2014, the Federal Ministry of Finance had issued a non-application ruling to that court resolution.

Since 2008, the interest barrier rule generally limits the tax deductibility of interest expense - irrespective of whether bank loans or shareholder loans are concerned - to 30% of the tax EBITDA and only allows for few exceptions.

Consequences

The final decision on whether the interest barrier rule violates the constitution now lies with the Federal Constitutional Court. It may take a few years until this Court will decide. Tax assessments need to be kept open.

Until the Federal Constitutional Court's decision is made, the tax administration may keep assessing taxes by applying the interest barrier rule and may still deny full interest deduction. It can be assumed, however, that all tax assessments with respect to the interest deduction will be "preliminary", i.e. subject to changes in favor of the taxpayer in case the Federal Constitutional Court should hold the interest barrier rule retroactively to be in violation of the constitution.

Should the Federal Constitutional Court, however, decide that the interest barrier rule either does not violate the constitution or that it should continue to apply although being unconstitutional until it is reformed, the tax assessments take binding effect.

In case taxes are assessed with limited interest deduction, although preliminary only, taxes assessed on this basis will become payable. A...

To continue reading

REQUEST YOUR TRIAL