Upgrading to Escape the Low Value-Added Trap in Global Value Chains: The Mediating Role of Strategic Learning Capability. (RESEARCH ARTICLE)

AuthorIslam, Mohammad Tarikul,Polonsky, Michael Jay,Khan, Zaheer,Islam, Mohammad Tarikul^Polonsky, Michael Jay^Khan, Zaheer
Published date01 February 2026

1 Introduction

Over the past two decades, global value chains (GVCs) have become a dominant framework for understanding the organization and structure of international business (IB) activities, diverging from the traditional internalization argument. The internalization thesis suggests that organizing value chain activities within the hierarchical governance of multinational enterprises (MNEs) is more efficient than relying on market-based transactions. However, globalization, liberal economic policies, and advancements in information and communication technologies have significantly lowered the cost of coordinating geographically dispersed operations (Debellis et al., 2024). As a result, MNEs have fragmented their value chains, internalizing high-value, knowledge-intensive activities (e.g., marketing) and outsourcing low-value, labor-intensive tasks to developing and emerging economies. In this pursuit of lower costs and higher quality, MNEs often adopt sourcing strategies described as a "race to the bottom," limiting suppliers' opportunities for upgrading (Barrientos et al., 2016: 1214). This study investigates a central question arising from this tension: how does participation in MNE-led GVCs support developing-economy suppliers in capturing greater value and moving beyond the low value-added trap?

Much of the existing literature has focused on governance as a mechanism through which MNEs control globally dispersed suppliers, typically through formal contracts aimed at maximizing efficiency (Debellis et al., 2024; Lechner et al., 2020). Yet recent work challenges this view, proposing that governance can also take a relational form, characterized by trust and social norms rather than formal control (Debellis et al., 2024; Kano, 2018; Verbeke, 2020; Verbeke et al., 2021; Xiao et al., 2020). Relational governance, defined as "the extent to which business exchanges are coordinated via social relations and shared norms" (Zhou & Xu, 2012, p. 679), can help mitigate the rigidities of contractual governance and promote mutually beneficial outcomes (Gereffi et al., 2021; Kano & Oh, 2020). However, research has paid limited attention to the temporal dimension of these relationships--specifically, how the length of buyer-supplier relationships shapes governance, learning, and upgrading outcomes (Buckley et al., 2019). As MNEs reconfigure their global operations over time, relationship duration can influence trust-building, resource sharing, and learning--key factors in suppliers' ability to upgrade.

This study addresses these gaps by drawing on resource dependence theory (Pfeffer & Salancik, 1978) and relational exchange theory (Macneil, 1978) to examine how developing-economy suppliers manage external dependencies within GVCs to enhance their upgrading potential. Upgrading refers to suppliers' strategies for value creation and capture, achieved by improving processes or products, or moving into higher value-added segments within GVCs (Gereffi et al., 2021). We argue that relational governance, particularly when embedded in long-term relationships, enables the development of strategic learning capabilities--defined as a firm's ability to derive knowledge from past actions and apply it to future strategic decisions (Anderson et al., 2009). These capabilities allow suppliers to translate knowledge gained from GVC participation into both low and high value-added upgrading (Gereffi et al., 2021; Epede & Wang, 2022; Sun & Zhou, 2025; Xiao et al., 2020). Using survey data from 376 Bangladeshi apparel suppliers--a globally connected and strategically important sector--we test our hypotheses regarding the direct and mediating roles of strategic learning, and the moderating effect of relationship length.

Our findings show that relational governance significantly contributes to suppliers' strategic learning capability, which in turn drives both low and high value-added upgrading. Relationship length strengthens the positive effect of relational governance on learning. Importantly, strategic learning capability mediates the relationship between relational governance and upgrading, with high value-added upgrading exerting a stronger influence on firm performance. These results offer new insights for GVC and resource dependence research by demonstrating that socially embedded governance mechanisms can help overcome opportunism and power asymmetries that undermine long-term GVC outcomes (Boehm, 2022; Poppo et al., 2008; Wang & Xin, 2024). They also highlight how proactive, learning-oriented suppliers can better manage dependencies, access partners' resources, and convert knowledge into meaningful upgrading and performance gains.

2 Theoretical Background and Hypotheses Development

2.1 Resource Dependence Perspective of Upgrading

The governance-upgrading relationship has been investigated through several theoretical lenses including transaction cost economics (TCE) (cf. Gereffi et al., 2005), power dependence theory (cf. Dindial et al., 2020), internalization theory (cf. Kano, 2018; McWilliam et al., 2020; Strange & Humphrey, 2019), the resource-based view (cf. Sinkovics et al., 2018), network theory (Kano, 2018), and resource dependence theory (RDT) (cf. Oliveira et al., 2021a, 2021b; Pham & Petersen, 2021; Wang & Xin, 2024). The transition from a pure internalization focused to hybrid organizational structure--combining internalized and externalized value chain activities to achieve higher efficiency--has presented significant challenges for MNEs in maintaining control over globally dispersed supplier networks. Early GVC research drew from TCE to examine the effectiveness of contractual governance in organizing GVC activities through external market-based contracting, arguing that such arrangements could benefit suppliers' upgrading (cf. Gereffi, 1999; Gereffi et al., 2005).

Another research stream extended this line of inquiry using internalization theory to identify mechanisms (e.g., leveraging power asymmetries) that minimize ex post transaction hazards associated with market contracting (cf. Narula, 2019). However, the governance-upgrading extends beyond ex ante contractual arrangement. Contracts are inherently incomplete and often fail to consider the social aspects of economic exchanges (Kano, 2018; Poppo & Zenger, 2002), resulting in relational frictions (Boehm, 2022; Sun & Zhou, 2025). Therefore, more recent studies have drawn on organizational theories such as RDT (cf. Oliveira et al., 2021a, 2021b;

Wang & Xin, 2024) to investigate the effectiveness of socially embedded relational governance in overcoming the rigidity of contractual governance and mitigating the asymmetrical dependency constraints that impede suppliers' upgrading in GVCs (cf. Kano, 2018; Soontornthum et al., 2020).

RDT (Pfeffer & Salancik, 1978) posits that organizations are open systems dependent on contingencies within the external environment. Interorganizational dependency arises from internal resource insufficiencies--financial, physical and information--and is characterized by both competitive and symbiotic interdependence (Pfeffer & Salancik, 1978). RDT contends that an organization's survival depends on: (i) its ability to acquire and maintain tangible and intangible resources; (ii) organizations exist within a network that affects access to and the flow of resources that are needed; (iii) organizations strive to strategically manage uncertainty to reduce their dependency on other organizations, while trying to make other organizations more dependent on them; and (iv) strategies to manage dependencies are influenced by both internal and external factors (Pfeffer & Salancik, 1978).

Although external environments provide opportunities to access partners' complementary resources, such dependencies can constrain autonomy and introduce uncertainty. Organizations can manage these uncertainties mutually or by exercising power to absorb, countervail, and avoid dependence constraints (Jiang et al., 2023; Sun & Zhou, 2025) through a range of governance strategies (1) (Pfeffer & Salancik, 2003). Building on RDT's competitive interdependence dimension, hierarchical (e.g., joint ventures) and contractual governance modes have been extensively studied to understand how corporate power can reduce interfirm uncertainty (Pfeffer & Salancik, 2003; Poppo & Zenger, 2002). However, the exercise of power leads to frictions, increasing transaction costs and reducing the benefits of GVC participation (Boehm, 2022; Sun & Zhou, 2025; Verbeke, 2020; Verbeke et al., 2021). It can also lead to inflexibility, stifling innovation and yielding suboptimal outcomes (Islam & Chadee, 2024; Wang & Xin, 2024). Thus, GVCs are increasingly adopting socially embedded governance arrangements to purposefully establish and maintain cooperative supply or distribution relationships to manage mutually beneficial external dependencies (Kano, 2018; Verbeke, 2020).

Yet, collaborative relational approaches to managing external dependencies-particularly in vertical exchange relationships--have received relatively limited attention in prior RDT research (Wang & Xin, 2024). Recently, a small but growing number of studies have adopted RDT to examine how GVCs facilitate bilateral dependence (Magnani et al., 2019), suppliers' complementary capability development (Dindial et al., 2020), or support ex post learning (de Oliveira et al., 2021a, 2021b; Xiao et al., 2020). This includes support for product and process innovation (Oliveira et al., 2021a, 2021b), market intelligence, and negotiation skills for product upgrading (Pham & Petersen, 2021) as well as the development of knowledge structures (Wang & Xin, 2024). We extend the application of RDT to GVCs by integrating the self-enforcing social norms embedded in relational governance (Coleman, 1990; Granovetter, 1985; Uzzi, 1999). Relational governance can efficiently overcome market imperfections and self-serving behavior of GVC participants by...

Um weiterzulesen

Jetzt Kostenlos Starten

Vollständigen Zugriff mit einer kostenlosen 7-Tage-Testversion freischalten

Verändern Sie Ihre juristische Recherche mit vLex

  • Vollständiger Zugriff auf die größte Sammlung von Common-Law-Rechtsprechung auf einer einzigen Plattform

  • Erstellen Sie KI-generierte Fallzusammenfassungen, die wichtige rechtliche Fragen sofort hervorheben

  • Erweiterte Suchfunktionen mit präzisen Filter- und Sortieroptionen

  • Umfassende juristische Inhalte mit Dokumenten aus über 100 Gerichtsbarkeiten

  • Vertraut von 2 Millionen Fachleuten, einschließlich führender internationaler Kanzleien

  • Greifen Sie auf KI-gestützte Recherche mit Vincent AI zu: Suchanfragen in natürlicher Sprache mit verifizierten Zitaten

vLex

Vollständigen Zugriff mit einer kostenlosen 7-Tage-Testversion freischalten

Verändern Sie Ihre juristische Recherche mit vLex

  • Vollständiger Zugriff auf die größte Sammlung von Common-Law-Rechtsprechung auf einer einzigen Plattform

  • Erstellen Sie KI-generierte Fallzusammenfassungen, die wichtige rechtliche Fragen sofort hervorheben

  • Erweiterte Suchfunktionen mit präzisen Filter- und Sortieroptionen

  • Umfassende juristische Inhalte mit Dokumenten aus über 100 Gerichtsbarkeiten

  • Vertraut von 2 Millionen Fachleuten, einschließlich führender internationaler Kanzleien

  • Greifen Sie auf KI-gestützte Recherche mit Vincent AI zu: Suchanfragen in natürlicher Sprache mit verifizierten Zitaten

vLex

Vollständigen Zugriff mit einer kostenlosen 7-Tage-Testversion freischalten

Verändern Sie Ihre juristische Recherche mit vLex

  • Vollständiger Zugriff auf die größte Sammlung von Common-Law-Rechtsprechung auf einer einzigen Plattform

  • Erstellen Sie KI-generierte Fallzusammenfassungen, die wichtige rechtliche Fragen sofort hervorheben

  • Erweiterte Suchfunktionen mit präzisen Filter- und Sortieroptionen

  • Umfassende juristische Inhalte mit Dokumenten aus über 100 Gerichtsbarkeiten

  • Vertraut von 2 Millionen Fachleuten, einschließlich führender internationaler Kanzleien

  • Greifen Sie auf KI-gestützte Recherche mit Vincent AI zu: Suchanfragen in natürlicher Sprache mit verifizierten Zitaten

vLex

Vollständigen Zugriff mit einer kostenlosen 7-Tage-Testversion freischalten

Verändern Sie Ihre juristische Recherche mit vLex

  • Vollständiger Zugriff auf die größte Sammlung von Common-Law-Rechtsprechung auf einer einzigen Plattform

  • Erstellen Sie KI-generierte Fallzusammenfassungen, die wichtige rechtliche Fragen sofort hervorheben

  • Erweiterte Suchfunktionen mit präzisen Filter- und Sortieroptionen

  • Umfassende juristische Inhalte mit Dokumenten aus über 100 Gerichtsbarkeiten

  • Vertraut von 2 Millionen Fachleuten, einschließlich führender internationaler Kanzleien

  • Greifen Sie auf KI-gestützte Recherche mit Vincent AI zu: Suchanfragen in natürlicher Sprache mit verifizierten Zitaten

vLex

Vollständigen Zugriff mit einer kostenlosen 7-Tage-Testversion freischalten

Verändern Sie Ihre juristische Recherche mit vLex

  • Vollständiger Zugriff auf die größte Sammlung von Common-Law-Rechtsprechung auf einer einzigen Plattform

  • Erstellen Sie KI-generierte Fallzusammenfassungen, die wichtige rechtliche Fragen sofort hervorheben

  • Erweiterte Suchfunktionen mit präzisen Filter- und Sortieroptionen

  • Umfassende juristische Inhalte mit Dokumenten aus über 100 Gerichtsbarkeiten

  • Vertraut von 2 Millionen Fachleuten, einschließlich führender internationaler Kanzleien

  • Greifen Sie auf KI-gestützte Recherche mit Vincent AI zu: Suchanfragen in natürlicher Sprache mit verifizierten Zitaten

vLex

Vollständigen Zugriff mit einer kostenlosen 7-Tage-Testversion freischalten

Verändern Sie Ihre juristische Recherche mit vLex

  • Vollständiger Zugriff auf die größte Sammlung von Common-Law-Rechtsprechung auf einer einzigen Plattform

  • Erstellen Sie KI-generierte Fallzusammenfassungen, die wichtige rechtliche Fragen sofort hervorheben

  • Erweiterte Suchfunktionen mit präzisen Filter- und Sortieroptionen

  • Umfassende juristische Inhalte mit Dokumenten aus über 100 Gerichtsbarkeiten

  • Vertraut von 2 Millionen Fachleuten, einschließlich führender internationaler Kanzleien

  • Greifen Sie auf KI-gestützte Recherche mit Vincent AI zu: Suchanfragen in natürlicher Sprache mit verifizierten Zitaten

vLex

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT